- Delivered on time, within budget, with all originally specified features and functions.
- Delivers positive business value exceeding development + operational costs.
When Does a Software Project Fail?
- Completed and deployed into use, but over budget, past deadline, and/or missing specified features.
- Caused by scope creep, optimistic estimates, or gold-plating.
- Cancelled prior to completion, or built and rejected by end users.
- Root Causes: Lack of user involvement, poor WBS, zero risk register, wrong technology stack.
CBA: Costs vs. Benefits Taxonomy
1. Development / Direct Costs
Outlays directly incurred to engineer the software: developer salaries, workstations, IDE/software licenses.
2. Setup & Conversion Costs
One-time transition costs: legacy database migration, parallel running periods, initial staff training.
3. Operational & Maintenance Costs
Recurring annual expenses over system lifetime: cloud/server hosting, helpdesk support, patches, renewals.
1. Direct Benefits
Immediate, measurable cash savings or new revenue (e.g., saving $15,000/yr in paper stationery and clerical overtime).
2. Assessable Indirect Benefits
Secondary efficiency gains reasonably estimated in money (e.g., 40% fewer data-entry errors saving 10 hrs/wk rework).
3. Intangible Benefits
Positive strategic impacts hard to express in exact dollars (corporate reputation, student satisfaction, staff morale).
Five CBA Financial Metrics
| Metric | Formula | Decision Rule | Key Limitation (Exam Favorite) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net Profit | Total Benefits − Total Costs |
Accept if > 0; higher looks better | Ignores initial investment scale AND timing of cash flows (time value of money). |
| Payback Period | Year before recovery + (Unrecovered / Recovery Yr Inflow) |
Prefer shortest payback (lower risk) | Ignores all cash flows AFTER breakeven date and ignores time value of money. |
| ROI / ARR | (Avg Annual Profit / Total Investment) × 100% |
Accept if ROI > target / bank rate | Uses simple accounting averages; ignores exact cash timing & compounding. |
| Net Present Value (NPV) | Σ [Net Cash Flow_t / (1 + r)^t] − Initial Cost_0 |
Accept if NPV > 0; pick highest NPV | Sensitive to discount rate r; absolute dollar figure ignores capital scale. |
| IRR | Discount rate r where NPV = 0 |
Accept if IRR > cost of capital | Assumes inflows reinvested at IRR; multiple roots if cash signs flip. |
Why NPV Wins Over Net Profit & Payback
NPV accounts for both the Time Value of Money ($1 today > $1 in 3 years) and all lifecycle cash flows from Year 0 to the final year.
Worked Case: Project Alpha vs. Beta
| Year | DF (10%) | Alpha | Beta |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yr 0 | 1.0000 | -$100,000 | -$100,000 |
| Yr 1 | 0.9091 | +$50,000 | +$10,000 |
| Yr 2 | 0.8264 | +$50,000 | +$30,000 |
| Yr 3 | 0.7513 | +$30,000 | +$100,000 |
Beta PV: 9,091 + 24,792 + 75,130 = $109,013
| Metric | Alpha | Beta |
|---|---|---|
| Net Profit | $30,000 | $40,000 |
| Payback | 2.0 years | 2 + 60/100 = 2.6 yrs |
| ROI | 10.00% | 13.33% |
| NPV (10%) | +$9,314 | +$9,013 |
Recommendation: Select Project Alpha
Even though Beta shows higher raw Net Profit ($40k vs $30k), Alpha delivers a higher NPV (+$9,314 vs +$9,013) and faster 2.0-year payback because its inflows arrive earlier.
CBA Exam Traps & PM Stewardship
- Year 0 Discounting: Year 0 happens TODAY! Its factor is always
1.0000, never1/(1+r)^1. - Picking by Net Profit Alone: Early-inflow projects often beat late-inflow projects on NPV—always rank by NPV.
- Implicit ROI Denominator: Always state
ROI = (Avg Annual Profit / Total Investment) × 100%explicitly (Hughes & Cotterell). - Ignoring Strategic Fit: Regulatory compliance or cybersecurity may justify a lower-NPV project in essays.
- Business Case Stewardship: Verify technical + CBA feasibility before heavy spend.
- Stepwise Planning: Realistic WBS & effort estimation (no SWAG budgets).
- Monitoring & EVM: Catch cost/schedule variances early.
- Change Control Board (CCB): Block unapproved gold-plating & scope creep.
- Stakeholder Alignment: Bridge non-technical sponsors and engineers.
Completed Concept 2: Project Failure & CBA
Next up: Step-Wise Project Planning, DISCO Objectives, WBS, Process Models, and CASE tools.